The Subway Series Spirals Into Trade Talks: Mets and Yankees Consider a Swap

This week marks the kickoff of the 2024 Subway Series at Citi Field, featuring the New York Mets and New York Yankees. Historically, trading between these two icons of the Big Apple is rare, but recent activity, including the Yankees’ trade of catcher Luis Torrens to the Mets for cash, has sparked speculation about the potential for more significant exchanges. Under the stewardship of Brian Cashman, these transactions have become a tantalizing possibility.

Amidst these trade whispers, one suggestion floating around could serve the interests of both teams well. The proposed swap sees each side relinquishing something to fill current gaps in their lineup.

Both teams stand to benefit considerably from the proposed trade. The Mets would be parting ways with their top left-handed bench hitter, a move seen as manageable given his limitations against left-handed pitching.

This opens up an opportunity for Brett Baty to step in, allowing Jeff McNeil to shift into a more flexible role, potentially covering the outfield, while Jose Iglesias takes charge of second base more frequently. On the other end, the Yankees, having recently promoted rookie Ben Rice to cover for Anthony Rizzo, might further bolster their lineup with former Met J.D.

Davis, creating a platoon situation at first base.

Though losing Stewart might not seem like a game-changer for the Yankees, his remaining minor league options present strategic value. This flexibility mirrors the handling of Ron Marinaccio, the pitcher the Mets would receive in the deal.

Since his 2022 debut, Marinaccio has showcased his talent with a 3.02 ERA over 110.1 innings. Despite a limited appearance this season, his 2.84 ERA over 19 innings suggests he could significantly reinforce the Mets’ bullpen, especially in light of Sean Reid-Foley’s injury.

Marinaccio could become an invaluable bullpen asset for the Mets until 2025, when his option to play in Syracuse expires. Not set to enter free agency until post-2028 season, he offers long-term value. To compensate for Stewart’s loss, the Mets might consider promoting Ben Gamel, whose Triple-A performance has been impressive.

The trade dynamics also involve discussions around Tyler Jay, a left-handed pitcher excelling in Triple-A, to balance the scales. Alternatively, a low-level prospect might be thrown into the mix, further adjusting the trade’s equilibrium.

However, the potential trade is clouded by uncertainties, including concerns about Starling Marte’s health and the integration of Davis into the Yankees. While immediate action is unlikely, the scenario could evolve significantly over the next month.

This trade, amid the high tensions and excitement of the Subway Series, illustrates the evolving relationship between the Mets and Yankees. As both teams jostle not just for city supremacy but for league dominance, their willingness to engage in mutual beneficial trades could mark a new chapter in their storied rivalry.